| Date | Rector | Patron |
| 1270 | Master Henry de Hamptesfort | Buckfast |
| 1310 | Richard de Colestane | Buckfast |
| 1311 | Master John de Lynham | Buckfast |
| 1317 | John Pollard | Buckfast |
| 1340 | Master Henry de Galmeton | Buckfast |
| 1342 | Sir John Perour | Buckfast |
| 1345 | Master Henry de Stawforde | Buckfast |
| 1348 | Richard Yuel de Stoke | Buckfast |
| 1349 | Sir Gilbert de Chysville | Buckfast |
| 1361 | Richard Halrigge | Buckfast |
| 1365 | Sir John Wademan | Buckfast |
| 1374 | John Lugens | Buckfast |
| 1386 | Sir Robert Palmer | Buckfast |
| | John Gaylord | Buckfast |
| 1413 | John Herword | Buckfast |
| 1441 | Sir John Hayggie | Buckfast |
| | Peter Stretch (resigned) | Buckfast |
| 1509 | Thomas Trewortha | Buckfast |
| 1536 | Thomas Bellworthy | Buckfast |
| 1536-37 | John Smyth | Buckfast |
| 1549 | Hugo Laine | Henry Denys |
| 1549 | John Dawne | |
| 1549-50 | John Taverner | |
| 1572 | William Voysse (also written as Vassa) | |
| 1607 | George Morten | Sir Thomas Wise |
| 1614 | Authany Gregorie | |
| | Trevithicke an intruder on whose deprivation | |
| 1662-63 | Edmond Hooper | Samuel Rolle |
| 1683 | Thomas Horndon | |
| 1714 | Charles Peters | |
| | Richard Ham (resigned) | |
| 1730 | Samuel Rolle | Robert Lord Walpole |
| 1734 | Thomas Ley | |
| 1747 | Edward Jackson | Robert Earl of Oxford |
| 1731 | William Paxton | |
| 1789 | James Messenger | |
| 1815 | John Knight (on whose cession) | The Lord Clinton |
| 1825 | John Knight (on whose death) | |
| 1845 | William Henry Cleave | |
| 1884 | Ernest Walter Field | |
| 1903 | Augustus George Alton | |
| 1910 | Samuel Stidson | |
| 1912-29 | William Edward Crosse-Crosse, Barrister | |
| 1925-29 | William Henry Smaile - Snr Perpetual Curate | |
| 1929-61 | William Henry Smaile - united benefice with Peters Marland | |
| 1962-63 | Suspension | |
| 1964-79 | Robert Frederick Grist | |
| 1980-87 | Ian Peter Gregory | |
| 1988 | John Patrick Benson - Priest in Charge | |
| 1989 | Nigel Gerrish Mead - Team Rector & Rural Dean | |
| 1992 | John Patrick Benson - Rural Dean | |